Sunday, April 11, 2010

Western Europe, circa 1500


Stephen Castaneda
Essay 1 – Paradigm Shift Around 1500 C.E.
Word Count:1182

If the seed of modernity was sewn during the Italian Renaissance, then the changes in Western European civilization around the beginning of the 16th century C.E. arguably represent its flowering. Charlemagne's (742-814) Empire would crumble into feudalism. The predominant socioeconomic arrangement became centered around large landowners and was built on the manorialism economic model, wherein serfs were bound to work the land of the local lord who provided the serfs with physical security from land-grabbing neighboring lords, and, according to Perry, the “right to cultivate fields.” Naturally, manorialism tended to lead society's focus away from cities and toward rural manors, and resulted in an entrenched system wherein there existed, as Perry sums it up, three social classes: “clergy who prayed, lords who fought, and peasants who toiled.” One can't help but draw comparisons between the plight of a medieval serf and that of a slave on an early American plantation.
This was, more or less, the socioeconomic structure that faced the Italian Renaissance and against which its leaders rebelled to plant the modern nucleus. Perry points out that during the Renaissance, “many medieval ways and attitudes persisted.” In his classic A History of Western Philosophy, Bertrand Russell argues that the remarkable cultural achievements that we tend to assume when we think of the Renaissance actually boiled down to a relatively small handful of geniuses under the patronage of very rich, and shockingly pragmatic feudal lords, as well as clergy who were equally rich and morally oblivious.
As an example we'll discuss the political philosopher Niccolò Machiavelli (1649-1527), arguably the most famous pure thinker of the Italian Renaissance, his ideal “new prince” expediently consolidates feudal power by manipulation, deception, even violence – whatever is most expedient (source book). Machiavelli demonstrates his keen perception of humanity with a long list of character traits of varying degrees of desirability. Acknowledging that each individual ruler brings their own personality and vices to the table, he warns the Prince not to strive to give up all vices, but simply “to avoid the scandal of those vices which would lose him the state.” On the other hand, however, he advises the ruler to outright ignore scandal incurred as the result of action that was expedient for the maintenance of the state. Interestingly, he advises mercifulness, but stresses that one “must, however, take care not to misuse this mercifulness,” citing as an example the harsh rule of Cesare Borgia which united Romagna (temporarily). In my opinion, Machiavelli would most certainly have approved the two nuclear attacks against Japan in the Second World War. It was the expedient thing to do, since the attacks' collateral damage was judged to be much smaller than that which would be incurred by attempting to forcibly occupy the Japanese mainland. What is remarkable about Machiavelli in relation to his era is that he asserts that a ruler should put the logistical needs of the state above any other ethical code. The dominant medieval political paradigm was that the monarch ruled at the pleasure of God almighty, and that the ruler was obliged to the church for ethical cues. In this system, the church was closely involved with much of the inner workings of government.
In fact, the clergy's questionable involvement in public affairs, coupled with their unscrupulous ways – which in all fairness was somewhat necessary for medieval movers and shakers – led some to reassess the boundaries of the clergy's jurisdiction. Two main players would, for very different reasons, almost inadvertently bring about one of the largest societal paradigm shifts in western history. The two figures are Martin Luther (1483-1546) and Henry VIII of England (1491-1547) and the instrument of change was the Protestant Reformation. Machiavelli had turned away from medieval politics, Renaissance artists from medieval art (which Perry tells us was almost exclusively religious), so did the Reformation turn away from medieval religious attitudes. Without going too deeply into their individual histories, Luther was a German clergy member who rebelled against the church's waning greed and blatant immorality, while Henry VIII was a worldly monarch, probably more motivated by an opportunity to break with the ethical and economic authority of Rome, which must have,to him, seemed half a world away.
Whatever its motivations, the Protestant Reformation happened quickly – Perry tells us that in the 30 short years prior to the death of Henry VIII, nearly 25% of western Europeans had converted to some form of Protestantism. The significance cannot be overstated – this is a populace that only half a century earlier sincerely believed the fate of one's everlasting soul depended entirely on Vatican intervention. As for religious freedom, we know that Protestantism believed in a democratization of faith – the Protestant God was more available, more personal, and Bibles were translated into common languages – but persecution by Protestants was often just as harsh as Papal persecution. The real revolution, as we discussed in class, was that in Protestant lands, the government was finally free from religious oversight. Machiavelli's prince now had a land to govern – not based on divine right and for the glorification of God, but based on the idea that the ruler's main concern should be the successful management of the state.
So we have discussed the beginnings of major paradigm shifts in art, politics, and religion. To finish up, I'll briefly discuss a fourth area of enlightenment just beginning to blossom around 1500 – that of science; or to maintain the tone of this essay, a break from medieval reliance on an Aristotelian/Biblical view of the natural world to that of an empirical and mathematical scientist. The eminent thinker in this regard is probably Copernicus. The week 2 handout even labels the paradigm shift the Copernican Revolution. It outlines 4 compelling (to medieval minds) arguments that the Earth was stationary, from purely scriptural – Psalm 93; to wildly speculative – that it's impossible for a body as heavy as the Earth to move, especially as fast as suggested; to the amazingly empirical – that if the Earth were spinning, why does an object dropped from a height fall straight down, instead of away from the direction of rotation? (The modern answer is two-fold. First, inertia causes the dropped object to move toward the direction of rotation, and second the object actually does fall away a bit, but the distance is much too small to measure). In my opinion, the most significant contribution of the Copernican Revolution lies hidden in the famous epicycles. The word for planet comes from a word meaning “wanderer” because they were not stationary against the stars, and some inexplicably moved for a time in one direction, reversed direction for a brief time, only to loop back and maintain a single overall orbit – something not even the sun did. The medieval cosmological model required the planet's rotation (around the Earth) to contain many epicycles. The Copernican model nearly eliminated epicycles, thereby giving modern scientist's one of their most cherished ideals – that all things being equal, the simpler model is almost always more accurate.

No comments: