Stephen Castaneda
HS240H First night assignment
According to Perry, the philosophes were the “combative intellectuals and pundits” who were “the leaders of the enlightenment.” These individuals of diverse backgrounds, though not entirely of the same mind on all issues, shared a few general beliefs that were inspired by the new science. Among their most cherished ideals were carefully ordered freedom, tolerance, and, according to Encyclopedia Britannica, a “conviction of the supremacy and efficacy of human reason.” In my assessment, the 17th century belonged to a small handful of geniuses, including Copernicus, Galileo, Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz, and Newton, whereas the 18th century philosophes represented a great democratization of science and thought that caused massive historical changes including the American Revolution.
Before discussing some of these great enlightenment leaders, let's define the enlightenment properly. According to the chronology presented by Perry, the enlightenment began in 1685 with the revocation of the Edict of Nantes – which justified the persecution of Protestants in France and caused mass exodus of its intellectuals – and ended in 1789 with the beginning of the French Revolution. As late as 1784, in his essay, “What is Enlightenment?,” Kant denied that his was a fully enlightened age, but rather was still an “age of enlightenment,” and he expresses great optimism for the future. As was typical of enlightenment thought, Kant rejected the traditional view of humans as mostly detestable, and argued that intellectual “laziness and cowardice” were the major factors holding humankind back, not lack of intelligence. He even attacks those of means who would outsource the “tedious job” of thinking to others. Clearly, enlightenment thinkers hoped that all people would take it upon themselves to pursue education and to question previously unquestionable institutions, such as political tyranny and the domination of the church.
Voltaire (1694–1778) was a Parisian poet, who traveled to the Dutch Republic and then to London, where he enjoyed enormous freedom of thought and “witnessed social and religious tolerance.”(Perry) He came to identify with the anger of exiled French Protestants toward the French church. In his writings, Voltaire condemns superstition, specifically the sentencing to death of “over a hundred thousand accused witches,” including one in Würzburg as late as 1749. He calls for complete tolerance of ideas, arguing that each citizen “be permitted to believe and think that which his reason rightly or wrongly dictates,” so long as those beliefs did not “disturb the public order.” This was in stark contrast to the strictness of the church in his time, which excommunicated or killed those who did not subscribe to the church's dogmas, no matter how “inaccessible to human intellect” they might be.
In order to understand Rousseau, we must first understand Hobbes, from whom Rousseau borrowed the idea that the governors served according to a social contract with the governed. Where Hobbes believed this to be a one-time contract creating a hereditary monarchy, Rousseau called for the contract to be continually renewed. According to Perry, Rousseau's political ideal was the city-state of ancient Greece, where all citizens participated in important decisions, and could be trusted to make decisions that were in the best interests of the state. This was in opposition to what he saw in his time as a corrupt system where the rich and powerful misused their positions to fortify their status and wealth, while oppressing the less fortunate. Interestingly, Perry tells us that Rousseau did not identify with the philosophes, who he accused of being “corrupted by easy living” and salon culture.
John Locke was a seventeenth century English political philosopher to whom we owe much of our modern ideas about the roles and responsibilities of government. According to Perry, he believed the right to govern was “derived from the consent of the governed and was a form of contract.” He believed in certain natural rights, such as life, liberty, and property and that if a government ruled arbitrarily and denied any of these rights, the people had the right to overthrow that government. From Locke's Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690), we see one of the great leaps forward in the history of epistemology in the concept of the tabula rasa, or blank slate, that represented each individual's mind at birth. He argues against religious revelation, asserting that all ideas must come from either “sensible qualities” such as things we taste, smell, see, or otherwise experience through our senses, or else from the “internal operations of our minds” – that which we are able to deduce logically from what we have observed.
To historians, enlightened despotism refers specifically to the High Enlightenment (second half of the eighteenth century) rulers “Frederick the Great in Prussia; Catherine the Great in Russia; Charles III in Spain; Maria Theresa and ...her son Joseph II in Austria; and Louis XV in France.” (Perry) To the philosophes, the phrase, probably coined by Diderot, referred to an ideal ruler who was strong and authoritative, but who allowed for freedom of exchange, both commercial and intellectual. In reality, Perry paints a less favorable picture of the enlightened despots, for whom enlightenment ideals were to be exploited for political expediency. For instance, Joseph II quickly reimposed censorship after French Revolution pamphlets began circulating under the liberalized publishing laws he enacted in the 1780's.
Finally we come to Adam Smith, who many have called the father of modern economics. Locke had already argued that the role of government was to promote the best interests of its citizens, and the new economic theory, personified in Adam Smith, asserted that the best economic interest was to allow business and trade to its own best interests. Smith saw the value of a good or service as the sum of the labor costs associated with its production. Labor was a commodity like any other, whose value is determined by the laws of supply and demand. In modern times, Smith and his laissez faire free-market ideas have been criticized for selling the public interest to the highest bidder. Another weakness in his theories lies in its reliance on self-interest governing the market, while it has been observed time and again that people and organizations often make erroneous decisions that are not in their own best interests, let alone in the interests of society.
References
Perry, Marvin. (2009). Western civilization. Boston, MA: 2009.
Perry, Marvin, Joseph Peden, and Theodore Laue. Sources of the Western Tradition Volume II. 7th ed. II. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin College Div, 2007.
philosophe. (2010). In Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved March 29, 2010, from Encyclopædia Britannica Online: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/456709/philosophe