Stephen Castaneda
First night assignment: The modern meaning of mythology
Mythology is a nearly mystical word almost begging not to have a definition pinned upon it. Of course we, as scholars, are somewhat loathe to discuss a topic without first putting forth our best effort to agree on a definition of all the terms we use. According to The New Student's Reference Work, the word mythology has two meanings. The more academic and etymologically correct definition is simply the study of various myths, in the same way that biology is the study of biological systems. This definition, like most self-referential definitions, is not very satisfying. The second definition, the one the authors claim is more common, is “a collection or system of myths held by a certain people.” They go on to define myth as a “sham history,” which, while patently false, is held by a certain people to be both true and extremely important. This definition was written nearly a century ago, and I would argue that it shows its age somewhat.
In his introduction to The Power of Myth, Bill Moyers discusses the relationship Joseph Campbell developed with the filmmaker, George Lucas. Clearly, Lucas and his colleague, Stephen Spielberg, are two of the great myth makers of my time. Moyers discusses Lucas's nod to Campbell in Star Wars, and there has been scholarly work on Spielberg's E.T. The Extraterrestrial as a Jesus myth (Tomasulo, 2001). I recall my father taking me to see Star Wars when I was just five, and can personally attest to the power the myth had over me. It had everything – a reluctant young hero, mystical powers some chose to use for good, others for evil, Ultimate triumph of the spirited guerrilla over an imposing and impersonal domineering power. All these things I experienced without either the benefits or biases that an older, more educated person would have brought to the theater, and I certainly was too young to catch the triumph of human over technology theme alluded to by Moyers. But I felt the “power of myth” rooting for Skywalker and friends. Thus, I think a more modern definition of mythology would not include the bit about it being held by some to be true. Certainly not even the most gullible and still-believing-in-Santa of my young friends ever believed Luke and Darth Vader really went head to head, not even a long time ago or far, far away. But the myth had much more power over my young mind than did, for instance, the myth of Robin Hood, which actually had some possible basis in history.
Which brings us to another flaw in the New Student's Reference's definition. Mythology need not necessarily be false. Moyers alludes to the myth of John F. Kennedy, and indeed, there exists a cultural mythology associated with the entire Kennedy family. An even more modern example is the myth of Barack Obama, whose rise to the most important office in the U.S. has great meaning for a great many peoples. For instance, to African Americans, he represents progress on the equality front. This feeling also extends to many other minority groups for whom the possibility of their sons or daughters someday rising to that kind of position is now a distinct reality. It even extends to many non-ethnic minorities. And then there is the manufactured, though no less real, myth of hope and change. I think it's safe to say that a large majority of those approximately 53% who voted for Obama believe (or at least believed) in the hope and change message. The point is that even though it can be argued that the hope & change mythology was entirely manufactured by political spin doctors, it is no less real to those who believe it, and to some extent, I think the entire nation uses it as the basis of the expectations we have of this president and his administration.
So clearly, our definition of the word mythology has changed somewhat in the last century, though we still share some rather powerful myths. When I took “mythology” in high school as recently as the late 1980's, the course definitely should have been named “Greek mythology,” as the rich diversity of world mythology was not to be found. Soon after high school, I forced my way through a second-hand copy of Campbell's The masks of God: creative mythology, though now I barely remember it beyond the vague recollection at being amazed by the parallels found in myths from peoples who geographically could not possibly share a cultural heritage. Looking at some of the reading assignments for this course, I look forward to experiencing that amazement again, this time through adult eyes.
References
Bierlein, J. F. (1994). Parallel myths. New York, NY: Random House, Inc..
Campbell, Joseph, Moyers, Bill, & Flowers, Betty. (1991). The Power of myth. New York, NY: Anchor.
The New Student's Reference Work/Mythology. (2007, November 29). In Wikisource, The Free Library. Retrieved 18:29, March 22, 2010, from http://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=The_New_Student%27s_Reference_Work/Mythology&oldid=510619
Tomasulo, F. P. (2001). The gospel according to Spielberg in E.T.: The extra-terrestrial. Quarterly Review of Film and Video, 18(3), 273-282. doi:10.1080/10509200109361529
No comments:
Post a Comment