I've already written about how much I like Comodo as a complete Internet security suite. I'd say it's biggest 'con' is that it is probably too complex for the casual user. I like it because of all it's settings, but it's probably pretty overwhelming for most. However, all the crazy settings really only apply to the IS suite. The antivirus options are just your basic 'set for auto updates' and 'set auto scan' options.
Since my primary environ is Linux, I'll briefly discuss scans that are more important than AV. Linux AV scanners are really meant for scanning attachments on mail servers because Linux isn't so susceptible to viruses. But I do run regular rootkit scans with chkrootkit and rkhunter. These do a lot of the same things that antivirus scanners do, but for *NIX environs. The obvious downside is that they are command-line tools, thus not for everybody. Also, when running interactively, by actually typing the command into a terminal, the warnings can be cryptic. The only way to get the full story is to look at the logs. I admit to not reading my logs as often as I prolly should.
John,
Sorry, I wasn't very clear in my post. Comodo is what I like for Windows machines. The *NIX command-line tools are rkhunter and chkrootkit. When run at the command line, they might, for instance, tell me that a certain executable is suspicious, but that's all. To learn more about why it considered the file suspicious and what action to take, I read my logs.
I've been looking for a nice project for my senior capstone, and designing GUI interfaces for these two programs might be just the thing.
Since my primary environ is Linux, I'll briefly discuss scans that are more important than AV. Linux AV scanners are really meant for scanning attachments on mail servers because Linux isn't so susceptible to viruses. But I do run regular rootkit scans with chkrootkit and rkhunter. These do a lot of the same things that antivirus scanners do, but for *NIX environs. The obvious downside is that they are command-line tools, thus not for everybody. Also, when running interactively, by actually typing the command into a terminal, the warnings can be cryptic. The only way to get the full story is to look at the logs. I admit to not reading my logs as often as I prolly should.
Steve
You talk about the cons of Comodo (namely command line interaction and cryptic messaging) but isn't that pretty much the norm for UNIX/Linux users? So, they should feel pretty much at home. Additionally, I don't know about the Comodo logs but I do know that most of the logs you find in the UNIX/Linux environment are also cryptic and difficult to follow unless you know what you are looking for. Of course, these cons are what make most people use Windows systems and that will keep the UNIX/Linux environment more secure as hackers always look for the big target.
John Zupan
John,
Sorry, I wasn't very clear in my post. Comodo is what I like for Windows machines. The *NIX command-line tools are rkhunter and chkrootkit. When run at the command line, they might, for instance, tell me that a certain executable is suspicious, but that's all. To learn more about why it considered the file suspicious and what action to take, I read my logs.
I've been looking for a nice project for my senior capstone, and designing GUI interfaces for these two programs might be just the thing.
John,
I've spent some time thinking about your post, and with the sole exception of the rootkit scanners, I can't think of a single administration or daily usage task for which there is no GUI tool available. Even the various servers have GUI tools. There are even GUI tools that help you monitor your logs.
So no, "command line interaction and cryptic messaging" are NOT "pretty much the norm for UNIX/Linux users." This is a common, but ultimately unfounded prejudice.
I can even perform administrative tasks on my non-GUI server using secure (SSH) GUI tools on an admin client.
Jared,
Here are the exact commands that I run:
sudo rkhunter --update; sudo rkhunter --check
sudo chkrootkit
I've spent some time thinking about your post, and with the sole exception of the rootkit scanners, I can't think of a single administration or daily usage task for which there is no GUI tool available. Even the various servers have GUI tools. There are even GUI tools that help you monitor your logs.
So no, "command line interaction and cryptic messaging" are NOT "pretty much the norm for UNIX/Linux users." This is a common, but ultimately unfounded prejudice.
I can even perform administrative tasks on my non-GUI server using secure (SSH) GUI tools on an admin client.
Stephen,
Thanks for listing a few of the root-kit scanners that you use for Unix and Linux. I like the fact that Linux is not very susceptible to viruses, but I am aware that there are still issues that can arise on the network, which I have Windows boxes on. Those pesky root-kits are a big pain, so I will look into the root-kit scanners you listed.
JC
Jared,
Here are the exact commands that I run:
sudo rkhunter --update; sudo rkhunter --check
sudo chkrootkit
No comments:
Post a Comment