Wednesday, April 21, 2010

religion term paper


Stephen Castaneda
The Kabah and the Hajj

As I pointed out in my essay on Islam, before taking this class, I was aware of the fact that Muslims faced Mecca during prayer. However, in my admitted ignorance regarding much of Islam, I had never asked myself the obvious question, “where do Muslims face if they are already in Mecca?” As a scientifically minded person, I have for as long as I can remember, always enjoyed anything having to do with the cosmos beyond Earth. Therefore, I was fascinated to learn the answer to my question about Muslim prayer, and I hope to use this paper as an opportunity to learn more about the Kabah, which is the cube-shaped box toward which Muslims face when they pray. I will also discuss a bit about the Hajj, the yearly pilgrimage to Mecca, especially as it relates to the Kabah.
As one might imagine, there are a number of web sites dedicated to the Kabah. Unfortunately, most of them are very religious in nature. The most secular definition I found about the Kabah was in the Dictionary of Architecture and Construction, which simply says “a cube-shaped, flat-roofed building in the center of the Great Mosque at Mecca; the most sacred shrine of the Muslims.” In fact, the word Kabah refers to its cube shape. Britannica Concise tells us that all Muslims face the box while praying, that it's four corners roughly point to the four compass points, and that inside there are “only pillars and silver and gold lamps.” But perhaps most importantly, built into its eastern corner is a meteorite called the Black Stone of Mecca.
History
I was unable to find any references to the historical origin of the Kabah. We know that it was there during Muhammad's time. Molloy tells us there were some 360 different idols there, mostly to Pagan gods. Among them, according to Aiden Bowers (1971), were the Daughters of God, who interceded with God on human's behlaf. Tradition tells us that the Kabah was first built by Abraham1 as a temple for the worship of Allah, or the One God. Some more likely historical builders are named by the web site http://kabahinfo.net include Abdullah lbn Al-Zubair in 65 H., AI-Hajjaj in 74 H., and the Ottoman Sultan, Murad Khan, in 1040 H., after the building was destroyed by flooding caused by heavy rain. King (1982) tells us that it was originally known as al-bayat, or “the house.” It was an open-roofed building a little taller than the height of a man, and probably took its present form during the seventeenth century, which was probably when it got the name Kabah, which means “the cubic box. Bowers says that the Arabs of Muhammad's time “were very much under the influence of Judaism,” but the idolatry that they practiced at the Kabah, was not allowed under Mosaic law. While most who came to Mecca practiced idolatry, there were some who saw it as an abomination and advocated a return to the pure Abrahamic religion. They were known as Hunefa, or “individuals out to seek the truth under the light of their own inner consciousness,” (Bowers, 1971) Muhammad was one of these Hunefa, and he believed Arabian society was in desperate need of moral and religious reform.
Without going too deeply into Islamic history, once Muhammad finally retook Mecca by force, one of the first things he did was to destroy the idols in the Kabah and in the marketplace. King (1982) tells us that though the faithful once prayed facing Jerusalem, that Muhammad had a revelation that the qibla, or the direction faced during prayer should be changed to facing the Kabah.
Naturally, as Islam quickly spread, the problem of calculating the qibla became one of great importance. Mosques were to be built with a prayer wall oriented toward the Kabah. The faithful were expected to be buried facing it, and “also were required to relieve themselves, expectorate, and perform sexual acts in a direction perpendicular to the qibla.”(King 1982). King also reminds us that from the eighth century, C.E, to the fourteenth century, the world's greatest mathematicians and astronomers were Muslim, and that determining the direction of the quibla was a favorite pastime. To calculate it, one must accurately measure one's latitude and longitude, as well as that of Mecca. Mathematicians had discovered both trigonometric and geometric algorithms. King estimates that within two hundred years of the death of Muhammad, that Muslim scholars could calculate the quibla for any spot in the Muslim world. They developed tables with the proper orientation for any degree of latitude and longitude, and “qibla boxes,” which contained a compass and engraved lists of qibla directions for major locations around the world. But the topic of King's article is that during medieval times, many Muslims – especially influential religious scholars – grew to distrust mathematicians and many Mosques from the period were built using more creative logic to determine the qibla. For instance, while he was in Medina, which is due north of Mecca, Muhammad said “what is between the east and west is a qibla.” Some scholars interpreted this to mean that the qibla was due south, no matter one's location.
Spiritual Meaning
The kabah has several names, according to http://kabahinfo.net including the Ancient House, Al-Bait, Al-Haram, Al-Bannia, Abraham's Building, Qibla, Al-Hamsaa, Al-Hums, and the Continuously-Visited House, We know that every Muslim who is able physically and financially must make the pilgriamage to Mecca at least once during one's life time. King (1982) tells us that “no non-Muslim can appreciate the elevation of the Muslim's soul when he or she beholds the Kabah. For Muslims, the Kabah is indeed the center of the world, the physical goal of their lives, a symbol of their religion, and, above all, a pointer to God Himself.” The web site http://kabahinfo.net tells us that tradition and history hold that there have been at least eleven builders, including the Angels, who originally built it directly underneath its celestial counterpart, the Most-Frequented House in Heaven. Another traditional builder, Adam, built it out of the stones carried by the Angels from five different mountains. Abraham, with his son Ismael, built it on the foundation built by Adam and the Angels. and Qusai, the fourth grandfather of Muhammad.
The information and quotes in the following paragraph regarding the “glories of the Sacred House” comes from http://kabahinfo.net. It is the first place of worship; the first house built by Adam, Abraham, and the angels; the first place circled in prayer ofter the great flood. It is “the assembly and return of all people,” which refers to the Hajj (which must be undertaken during the month of Dhu al-Hijra), and the Umrah (which is the pilgrimage that can be taken at any time of year). The pilgrimage can be completed either for repentance, “or for securing a reward.” The faithful may reside near it for a time, as a sort of religious retreat. It can improve one's earthly affairs, both secular and religious. Accordingly, the faithful “eagerly return to it.” Visitors receive rewards in the afterlife, including some reward or secure place. Anybody who visits it with the sole purpose of prayer will “definitely have all his sins erased as if he were a newly-born child,” and anyone who dies on the way there will enter Paradise unquestioned. Veneration of the Kabah is the only source of the benevolence bestowed by God upon Islam, and if such glorification were removed, it would result in the “total destruction” of Islam. Circumabulating the House in prayer seven times is the equivalent of offering oneself as a slave to Allah, and those who do so become the topic of casual conversation between Allah and the Angels. Due to the profound forgiveness of sins that accompanies repeatedly doing so, “circumambulators should then adhere to uttering words of praise, supplication and acclamation.” As an incentive to ensure pilgrims arrive year-round, circumambulation during inclement weather is especially austere, and those who do so will be fittingly rewarded for their sacrifices. According to the site:
“Finally, Allah appointed the Ka'bah, the Sacred House, as an establishment for men, that is, the centre of their material and tangible system as well as their spiritual one from which they emerge and to which they return. It is the outstanding landmark that unifies their objectives, destinies and life affairs, from which radiates the light of monotheism which Muslims transmit to all parts of the world.”
As a scriptural argument for the importance of the Kabah, The Qu'aran reads "We see the turning of your face (for guidance), to the heavens: now shall we turn you to a Qibla that shall please you. Turn then your face in the direction of the Sacred Mosque: wherever you are, turn your faces in that direction. The people of the book know well that that is the truth from their Lord, nor is Allah unmindful of what they do." ( 2:144)
Details
Finally, for some concrete facts on the Kabah, the best resource I found by far was the Wikipedia article, from which the following details are gathered. Angels notwithstanding, the granite from which the walls are constructed comes from the mountains near Mecca. The base is made of marble, and stands ten inches high. The rectangular structure is about 43 feet high, with sides about 36 by 48 feet. The eastern corner, which contains the Black Stone, is known as “the Black Corner,” the northern is the “Iraqi Corner,” the western is the “Levantine Corner,” and the southern is the “Yemeni Corner.” It is covered by a black silk drape that is known as the kiswah. It is carefully handcrafted with golden embroidery. The kiswah must be replaced each year at a cost of 17 million Saudi riyals (about 4.5 million dollars). The old one is cut up and gifted to important or prominent pilgrims. Entry into the Kabah is permitted rarely on special occasions and only to small groups. The interior floor is marble and limestone, the walls are marble halfway up to the roof, and covered by curtains that are perfumed by caretakers the rest of the way. The marble walls have tablets inset with inscriptions from the Qur'aran and the curtains are embroidered with verses in gold thread.
References


Black Stone. (2010, April 21). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 23:44, April 21, 2010, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Black_Stone&oldid=357477926
Dewick, E. (1955). Modernist movements in the non-Christian religions. Modern Churchman, 45(2), 97-108. Retrieved from ATLA Religion Database with ATLASerials database.
Bowers, A. (1971). Towards an understanding of Islam. AFER, 13(4), 305-314. Retrieved from ATLA Religion Database with ATLASerials database.
King, D. (1982). Faces of the Kaaba: It's a primitive observatory, weather vane, and pointer to God. Sciences, 22(5), 16. Retrieved from Academic Search Premier database.
Kiswah. (2010, January 10). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 23:46, April 21, 2010, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kiswah&oldid=337007468
Kaaba. (2010, April 21). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 23:43, April 21, 2010, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kaaba&oldid=357478020
Kaʿbah. (2010). In Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved April 21, 2010, from Encyclopædia Britannica Online: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/309173/Kabah
Kabah. (2006). In Britannica Concise Encyclopedia. Retrieved from http://www.credoreference.com.dml.regis.edu/entry/ebconcise/kabah
Kaba, Kaaba, or Kabah. (2005). In The Crystal Reference Encyclopedia. Retrieved from http://www.credoreference.com.dml.regis.edu/entry/cre/kaba_kaaba_or_kabah
Kaaba. (2006). In Dictionary of Architecture and Construction. Retrieved from http://www.credoreference.com.dml.regis.edu/entry/mhbuilding/kaaba

1Dewick (1955) tells us the cautionary tale of Dr. Tärä Husain, who was nearly expelled from the teaching staff of El Azhar University for questioning whether the temple was really built by Abraham. He had to proclaim that his paper was only academic, and that it did not in any way affect his views as a Muslim.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Islam


Stephen Castaneda
Islam

I can probably count on one hand the number of facts I know for certain about Islam. After successfully completing World Religious Traditions I and II to this point, Islam is easily the faith about which I knew and understood the least entering the course. For instance, one thing I knew, or rather thought I knew, was that depictions of the prophet were taboo, even by non-Muslims. But as we learned in class last week, this is actually a fairly modern development in the history of Islamic Law. In a similar vein, I expect these next few pages to be a fantastic opportunity to learn more about this religion that so few westerners understand, and so many of us fear.
We know Muhammad (570-632 C.E.) was born in Mecca, which Molloy describes as having a very diverse religious landscape that included Judaism, Christianity, and Zoroastrianism, as well as countless local practices that worshiped nature spirits, tribal gods, and jinni. Pilgrims came to see a meteorite that is covered by square shrine called the Kabah. At 27, Muhammad married a widow 15 years his senior, which “brought financial, spiritual, and emotional support.”(Molloy) He received his first revelation at 40 while meditating, as he frequently did, in the caves near Mecca. He was shown a manuscript and commanded by the angel Gabriel to make a copy of it.
Skipping many historical details for the sake of space, Muhammad and his followers initially met with great resistance and even persecution. In the Qur'an 52:30-49, he answers accusations that he is only a poet, that he made everything up, and that he is only out for financial gain. He fled Mecca in 622 C.E., which is the year the Islamic calendar begins, because this marked the first major acceptance by a people, as well as the start of the Islamic community, or umma. The Qur'an 9:40 tells us that during this time, Muhammad enjoyed the tranquility of God, who sent invisible warriors to help him exalt the Word of god. Finally he returned to Mecca by force in 630 C.E. and he destroyed the hundreds of diverse religious images in the Kabah as well as in the marketplace. He died in 632, and in his final sermon, he spoke about putting aside tribal squabbles in favor of a united brotherhood of believers. One might argue that unification was the underlying theme of his entire ministry, even if it required violence to achieve. To be fair, he wasn't by any estimation the first or last of history's greatest unifiers who favored the sword. Of his death, the Qur'an says in 21:34 that all souls must taste death, and that Muhammad could be no exception.
Molloy tells us that the words Islam and Muslim are related to the Arabic salam and the Hebrew shalom, both of which mean “peace,” and refer to the inner peace one may experience by submitting to God. An Abrahamic monotheistic religion, Islam believes God carefully controls every detail that occurs on Earth1, and as Molloy points out, “the notion of God's power and transcendence receives the greatest emphasis in Islam.” As a result, for most Muslims, Islam plays an integral part of daily life, as we shall see in the next paragraph. The name Allah literally means “the God” and is not one of the names of God, of which there are 99, emphasizing that God is not abstract, but very personal. Among the names listed in the Qur'an 59:22-24 are the Compassionate, the Giver of Peace, the Keeper of Faith, the All-Powerful, the Mighty, and the Wise One. Though Muslims believe all Muhammad's religious ideas came directly from God, Islam shares much in common with Judaism, Christianity, and Zoroastrianism, all of which Muhammad would have been exposed to in Mecca. The religion focuses heavily on ethics and morality.
As stated before, Islam plays an important role in the daily life of most devout Muslims. To demonstrate, I will briefly discuss each of the Five Pillars of Islam, which all Muslims must accept and practice. First is Shahadah, or creed. The fundamental creed of Islam is La ilaha illa Allah wa-Muhammad rasul Allah, or There is no god but God and Muhammad is the prophet of God. This phrase is repeated daily during prayer, it is the first thing newborns hear and is supposed to be the last words of Muslims. Second is Salat, or prayer. One of the few things I already knew about Islam before the course, was that they are called to prayer five times each day. I also knew that Muslims faced Mecca during prayer, but I did never asked myself the obvious question “where do Muslims in Mecca face?” the answer, as I shall expound on in my term paper, is that they face toward the Kabah. There are many other rules regarding prayer, including that Fridays are the day for public prayer. The third Pillar is Zakat, or charity to the poor. While each Muslim must pay 2.5% of their worth to the poor each year, Muhammad also stressed the social equality of all people. The fourth Pillar is Sawm, or fasting during Ramadan, the ninth month of the Islamic calendar. Those observing the fast abstain from all food, liquid, tobacco, and sex from dawn until dusk. The fifth Pillar is Hajj, or pilgrimage to Mecca. Every able Muslim is expected to complete the pilgrimage at least once in their lifetime. There will be more about the pilgrimage in my term paper. Other restrictions held by devout Muslims include not consuming pork or alcohol, prohibition on usury and gambling, and the circumcision of males, among many other rules.
Time and space force me to skip much of the material this week, so I will conclude with a discussion of the role of women in Islam. We know that Semitic society in Muhammad's day was very patriarchal, and that Islam has been faithful to that tradition. However, for his time, Muhammad was something of a champion of women's rights. Molloy outlines four areas of reform called for. First, he forbade infanticide, whose victims were usually female. Second, he limited the number of wives a man could marry to four, and said all wives should be equally treated. Third was equality of the sexes in what Molloy calls “basic rights,” including the right to initiate divorce, collect alimony, and property rights. Finally, women were to perform most of the same religious duties as men. That being said, the Qu'aran reading on the subject of women presented by Van Voorst has some rather incriminating evidence. It says God made men superior to women, and says women should be beaten if one so much as fears disobedience from them. Menstruation is seen as an illness, and women are unclean and untouchable during that time.
1As a personal observation, I have a hard time imagining how Islam can resolve this belief with the Biblical story of original sin, which clearly demonstrates that the Abrahamic God gave humans free will.

Visit to Basilica


Stephen Castaneda
Western Religious Traditions 2010Sp5W3
Site Visit Report

As a newborn, I was baptized into the Roman Catholic faith, though neither of my parents were devout, and they divorced when I was still very young. My mom later got “saved,” and I've always considered myself an Evangelical, maybe Pentecostal Protestant. So for my site visit, I chose to observe a Catholic mass, specifically, mass of the Third Sunday of Easter, April 18th, 2010 at the Cathedral Basilica of the Immaculate Conception in downtown Denver.
As to the context of the service in the life of the community, my friend who would be accompanying me and myself actually chose mass for this project because of the frequency with which it occurs. My other choice would be to go to a so-called mega-church, but they did not meet at very convenient times. The Basilica offered mass 5 times on Sundays, 3 times on weekdays, and twice on Saturdays. For my friend and I, it was much more convenient to schedule mass than Protestant services, which sometimes only occur once or twice on Sunday and maybe Wednesday evening. As I understand it, devout Catholics might try to attend mass every day.
April with Pope Saint Pius X

The role of scripture was very prominent, including several solemn readings from the Bible, after which the leader of the ceremonies (I'm ignorant as to whether to call this person the priest or ?) would say “The word of the Lord,” and to which the congregation replies “thanks be to God.” The readings included a reading from the Gospels, which today was from John 21. The reader first says “a reading from the holy Gospel according to John,” and the congregation replies “Glory to you, Lord.”
For the visual aspects, I will defer to my camera except to say that even though I consider myself relatively modern and immune to emotional appeals, it is almost impossible not to be overwhelmed by the art and architecture which is specifically designed to remind us of the greatness and glory of God and church.

Of the three orientations of the sacred, the service is definitely dominated by the liturgical, standing upon solemn ceremony. But again, the art and architecture is so overwhelming that I think it adds a dimension of the mystical to the overall experience. Also, I'd like to be a bit presumptuous and add a fourth dimension of the sacred that I've noticed since my time at Regis, and also in the service I attended – the intellectual. I think modern Catholicism, perhaps more than any other tradition, closely integrates intellectual appeals evidenced by its study of philosophy and theology. For instance, in the Evangelical services to which I'm accustomed, when it comes time to ask for money, usually a very emotional appeal is presented. In the Catholic service, an appeal to reason was presented in the form of a letter from the Archbishop which was read aloud. He was asking parishioners to make a substantial yearly donation to help save the church significant postage and printing costs. Once your annual pledge was made, you would be removed from the financial appeals mailing list. Smart.
To paint the Basilica in the larger picture of the Catholic religion, I shall quote their mission statement as presented on their website, www.denvercathedral.org. “The Cathedral Basilica of the Immaculate Conception serves as the Mother Church of the Catholic faithful in northern Colorado.”
It's hard to project myself onto the parishioners and presume what they are getting out of it. I couldn't help but think that nobody in their right mind would choose to be Catholic, and that for many of them, it was the fulfillment of tradition.
I did not conduct an interview, specifically because I knew I was going to go over the two pages length for this report that was recommended in class!
I personally thought the service was very boring. I asked my friend why they asked us to stand and sit so many times, and she replied “probably to keep people from falling asleep.” If anything, the only change in my assumption was that the service was more boring than I had thought it would be. I could, however, sympathetically relate to anyone's religion. I think the tradition, solemnity, and ritual can be very appealing.

French Revolution and Napoleon


Stephen Castaneda
Week 4 Questions

  1. List and briefly describe the causes of the French Revolution.
    1. First Estate: French Catholic clergy
      1. owned 10% of land
      2. paid “free gift” instead of taxes
      3. criticized as more interested in wealth and power than spirituality
    2. Second Estate: Nobility
      1. owned ¼ to 1/3 of land.
      2. Usually owed no taxes or used influence to evade taxes
      3. Aprx 350,000 members divided in classes
        1. Nobles of the sword
          1. could trace aristocratic heritage for centuries
          2. not always rich
          3. King's army officers
          4. had titles and positions, sometimes at Versailles, but rarely performed useful functions
        2. New nobility
          1. granted nobility by monarchy, usually due to wealth or strengthen monarch's position – weakening the old nobility.
          2. Nobles of the robe – purchased judicial offices in high law courts
      4. Liberal members of nobility, including many philosophes,
          1. had much in common with bourgeoisie
          2. Saw king's difficulties in 1788 as opportunity to instill enlightened government
      5. Other nobles opposed reform in favor of their own interests
    3. Third Estate
      1. Bourgeoisie – traders, manufacturers, lower-level government officials, master artisans, bankers, doctors
        1. Sometimes wealthy, but hard to get to be nobility
        2. Owned aprx 20% of land
        3. Wanted
          1. attractive positions to be available to all men of talent
          2. Parliament
          3. constitution limiting king's power and establishing basic freedoms, fair trial, eliminate government waste, fraud, & interference in business affairs
      2. Peasantry – Rural poor
        1. owned 30-40% of land but few had large enough plot to make a living
        2. supplemented income in variety of ways
        3. many had no land and had to survive of other's supplemental income revenues
        4. increasingly forced into beggary
        5. Seem to have paid most of the taxes, not to mention land fees and tithes
        6. cost of living growing much more quickly than wages
      3. Urban laborers – journeymen, day laborers, servants, factory workers
        1. also saw significant COL increases
        2. food shortages
    4. Grievances of the Third Estate (29 March, 1789) (source book)
      1. equal treatment
      2. inclusion in political discourse
      3. no arbitrary arrest and speedy trial
      4. freedom from postal censorship
      5. property rights
      6. abolish excessive taxation
      7. Taxation of all classes equally
      8. Justice reforms
        1. no more sales of offices
        2. reduction in number of offices
        3. law school reforms
        4. open military service to 3rd estate
      9. Financial reforms
        1. uniformity on commodities tax
        2. elimination of salt tax “if possible”
        3. permanent repeal of all fur tax
        4. abolition of “all useless offices”
      10. Agricultural reforms
        1. Nobility's hunting rights should not adversely affect landowner
        2. Freedom to use any mill, oven, etc. that until then peasants had to pay the lord for
        3. Suppression of militia in favor of volunteer army paid for by provinces.
  2. Describe how the French Revolution helped shape the modern western world.
    1. Destroyed hierarchical and corporate structure of Old Regime
    2. promoted interests of middle class bourgeoisie
    3. quickened growth of modern state
    4. weakened aristocracy
    5. gave birth to modern nationalism
    6. Rise of revolutionary mentality
  3. Describe the reforms Napoleon made in
    1. administration – strong central government
      1. Administrative uniformity throughout France
      2. centralized, successfully run state helped collect taxes for wars
      3. censorship and control of media
    2. relations between church and state – Napoleon was deist or atheist
      1. reconciled church and state which was disrupted during the revolution
      2. Concordant of 1801 officially recognized Catholicism
      3. To Napoleon, religion was an effective tool for social unification
    3. education and social welfare
      1. favored public education, which served two purposes:
        1. Provided him with educated bureaucrats
        2. chance to indoctrinate the young
      2. Modern French school system is highly centralized

Friday, April 16, 2010

Denial-of-Service



The purpose of this paper shall be first to examine some of the general characteristics of a computerized denial-of-service (DOS) attack, secondly to briefly describe a few actual attacks, and finally to suggest some best practices for defending against DOS attacks. According to a 1997 cert.org whitepaper on the subject, a DOS attack “is characterized by an explicit attempt by attackers to prevent legitimate users of a service from using that service.” Examples given include brute force attempts to “flood” a target network or service with false requests, attempts to disrupt connections between two target machines, attempts targeting a particular individual, or attempts to disrupt a target system. I think the latter two are a little broad to be included in our definition, however even the name denial of service is enough to describe the act of disrupting legitimate use of some service. The targeted service is often a network resource, but could be anything – disk space, a printer, even computational cycles. However, if we are to split hairs, botnets, which illegitimately use computational cycles, are not technically DOS since the attacker's goal is usually to steal processor cycles, not necessarily to deny them from their legitimate user. In fact, as I've pointed out on the discussion board, someone running a botnet might be very careful not to place a noticeable strain on system resources in order to evade detection. We shall, however, see that the botnet is one of the most powerful tools in a cracker's repertoire for perpetrating DOS attacks.
The CERT (1997) article identifies three categories of modes, or types of attack. They are the consumption of scarce resources, the destruction or alteration of configuration data, and the physical destruction or alteration of network components. While the latter two are particularly pernicious, we shall concern ourselves with the first one, consumption of resources. This category is further broken down into four types. They are:
  1. Network connectivity. This is the most frequent type of attack, and is an example of an asymmetric DOS attack – meaning the attacker does not need to match bandwidth with the server. The cited example is the TCP “SYN flood” attack described in 1996. Here, the attacking machine initiates a TCP connection, but leaves the server waiting for the connection to be completed with a client which has been carefully designed never to do so. The server has a limited number of processes devoted to connections, so a properly configured PIII machine on a 56k dial-up connection could theoretically shut down a relatively beefy server, regardless of it's bandwidth.
  2. Using your own resources against you. The example attack, also described in 1996, is the UDP port DOS attack, which takes advantage of the fact that “when a connection is established between two UDP services, each of which produces output, these two services can produce a very high number of packets that can lead to a denial of service on the machine(s) where the services are offered.”(CERT) In this particular instance, the targeted protocols are chargen and echo which, when connected to each other, either on the same machine, or two different ones, generate enough chatter to not only shut down both services, but potentially the network connection between them.
  3. Bandwidth consumption. This is, until I researched this paper, what I thought of as the typical DOS attack. The strategy is to flood the targeted network with an enormous number of packets, essentially crowding out legitimate uses. In certain circles, this kind of brute-force attack might not be considered among the more elegant, but if anything that makes it more dangerous, since these attacks can be carried out by those with relatively little sophistication.
  4. Consumption of other resources. Just as it sounds, this category is diverse, but the common factor is the consumption of resources, which might include...
    1. System data structures, such as “process identifiers, process table entries, process slots, etc.” (CERT, 1997). The system's process table may be completely filled, or the machine can simply be bogged down by too many processes to effectively switch among them.
    2. Disk Space, including bombarding a particular email server with spam, intentionally generating warnings and errors that fill up log files, abuse of public FTP servers, or targeting any similar data stream that may be written to without bounds.
    3. Miscellaneous resources, including printers, backup devices, and network connections.

So now that the situation sounds completely hopeless, what can be done to protect against DOS attacks? Again, the 1997 CERT whitepaper outlines several best practices:
  1. The TCP SYN flooding attack described above can be defended by filtering at the router level, as well as by patches from OS vendors.
  2. Disabling all unnecessary services.
  3. Enforcing disk quotas and effectively using disk partitions. As a Linux user, I am familiar with the practice of creating separate partitions for log files, or FTP data.
  4. Establishing performance baselines against which the system may be periodically checked for signs of degradation, which might indicate a DOS attack.
  5. Routinely reassessing the physical security of components.
  6. Using a tool such as the classic UNIX utility Tripwire, which detects and reports changes to configuration files.
  7. Investing in and maintaining fault-tolerant networks and spare capacity that can mitigate damage in case of successful attack.
  8. A security standard that is excellent advice in many contexts – early and frequent backups.
  9. The equally familiar rules regarding password policies, especially regarding sensitive accounts.
Finally, it's hard to estimate the potential for financial harm that can be caused by DOS attacks, but we can easily imagine situations in which the loss can be significant. For instance, a struggling on-line retailer could be financially ruined by a successful DOS attack on an important shopping day. As if to underscore the seriousness of DOS attacks, the 1997 CERT whitepaper concludes with the advice that victims in the United States should contact their local FBI authority.
References
Carnegie Mellon University (1997). Denial of Service Attacks. Retrieved April 16, 2010 from Carnegie Mellon University, cert.org: http://www.cert.org/tech_tips/denial_of_service.html.
Carnegie Mellon University (1996). CERT® Advisory CA-1996-21 TCP SYN Flooding and IP Spoofing Attacks. Retrieved April 16, 2010 from Carnegie Mellon University, cert.org: http://www.cert.org/advisories/CA-1996-21.html.
Carnegie Mellon University (1996). CERT® Advisory CA-1996-01 UDP Port Denial-of-Service Attack. Retrieved April 16, 2010 from Carnegie Mellon University, cert.org: http://www.cert.org/advisories/CA-1996-01.html.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Protestantism Paper


Steve Castaneda
Protestantism

The historical significance of the Protestant Reformation can not be overstated. The Roman Church had not been seriously challenged in it's thousand-year history, and for the vast majority of Europeans, all roads to salvation lead to Rome. And even though the fate of their eternal souls depended upon it, in the thirty short years after Martin Luther's initial Ninety-Five Theses (1517), nearly 25% of the western European population had embraced one form or another of Protestantism (Perry, et.al, 2009). Renaissance politics were notoriously lacking in ethics. The church was a major player in politics, and owned fortunes in currencies and real estate. Luther's initial argument was against a common practice of the church – the selling of indulgences, a fee paid to clergy on behalf of deceased loved ones whose souls might be trapped in Purgatory. One might argue that the church was imposing a tax on souls, and Luther angered many powerful members by opposing the lucrative practice, and he was excommunicated in January of 1520 (Wikipedia).
Finally, the Diet of Worms (1521) issued a warrant to arrest Luther for heresy (Wikipedia). His life was in great danger, but he found a powerful ally in the Elector of Saxony, Frederick III. Under Frederick's protection, he completed one of his more important works, the translation of the Bible into German, thereby democratizing access to the holy work(Wikipedia). Similarly, he called for liturgy in German as well as the traditional Latin. This was so important because it represented one of Luther's core ideals – that the individual's relationship with God was personal, and did not require intervention from Rome. He agreed with Rome that humans were sinners, but Catholic salvation of the day required good works as well as faith, not to mention faithful observance of the tithe. Luther argued that humankind was saved by faith alone through the grace of God. Lutheranism spread through northern Germany, Scandinavia, the Baltic states, and was exported to the United States (Molloy).
Another form of Protestantism was inspired by the French theologian, John Calvin (1509-1564). Calvin saw humans as not only sinful, but drawn toward evil. He also agreed with Luther that one's good or sinful deeds did not determine salvation, but Calvin believed that the deeds one performs on Earth are actually indicators of one's eventual verdict on judgment day. (Molloy) In other words, Calvinism believes in predestination – the idea that salvation or damnation is determined before birth. If one reflects upon God's omniscience, it's fairly easy to deduce that God knows the fate of a soul before birth, thus no amount of human works or faith should be powerful enough to “trick” God by changing the fate of the soul during one's lifetime.
Molloy tells us that Calvin studied law at university, and suggests this may have influenced the Calvinist emphasis on God as Judge. Like many French Protestants, persecution drove him into exile. He moved to Geneva, where he found a receptive populace already considering reforms due to the prior work of the reformer, Huldrych Zwingli (1484-1531). Where Luther had kept many aspects of the Catholic liturgy, Calvin rejected any tradition whose origins could not be found in the Bible. He rejected art in the church, promoted unaccompanied congregational singing, and placed the sermon as the focus of the service (Molloy).
Calvinism would have no bishops to appoint ministers, who were instead “called” by a democratic council from each congregation. Because this practice threatened the powerfully established centralized structure of other churches, Calvinists were often persecuted. The exile they would endure resulted in the wide geographic dispersion of their faith, which spread to New England and other areas of North America, Holland, Scotland, Switzerland, and Scotland, where the bishop-less church structure was refined. Probably the best-known modern Calvinist faith is Presbyterianism (Molloy).
Another major player in the Protestant Reformation was Henry the VII of England, whose death in 1547 marked the end of the thirty-year period previously discussed during which Protestantism swept western Europe. From the Encyclopedia Britannica's (eb.com) entry on the Church of England, we know that the English church dates to the conversion of the Anglo-Saxon invaders to Catholicism by the first Archbishop of Canterbury, Augustine (d. 604 C.E.). Since Henry broke with catholicism, it has been known as the Church of the Anglican Communion, and “As the successor of the Anglo-Saxon and medieval English church, it has valued and preserved much of the traditional framework of medieval Roman Catholicism in church government, liturgy, and customs, while it also has usually held the fundamentals of Reformation faith.” (eb.com) Henry's motivations may have been more political and self-serving than other, more theological reformers, but the outcome was still dramatic. To be fair, we see from the history of the Anglican treatment of the Irish that Catholicism had no monopoly on faith-based persecution.
Finally, because Protestantism has as one of its core values the idea that the Bible is somewhat open to individual interpretation, many more Protestant faiths are grouped together under the umbrella heading Sectarianism. Anabaptists believe in the need for baptism of adults as a sign of inner conversion, and their faith is the source of Mennonite and Amish sects. Baptists are the largest Protestant denomination in the United States. Quakers are pacifists with no clergy who have a mostly silent and ritual-free church service. The Shaker movement grew from the Quaker movement and is named after a devotional dance performed at their services. They formed largely agrarian societies, mostly in new York and new England, and advocate complete celibacy. The Pentecostal movement, as Molloy tells us, has been very prolific in the last century and emphasizes emotion in the church service. Finally, the Methodist church grew from a devotional movement within the Church of England, and was named for the methodical devotional system studied by Charles Wesley. The movement was expanded by his brother, John Wesley, who wrote 6000 hymns.

References
Perry, Marvin, Chase, M., Jacob, J.R., Jacob, M.C., & Von Laue, T.H. (2009). Western civilization: Ideas, Politics, and Society Volume 2: From the 1600's. 9th ed. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
Church of England. (2010). In Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved April 14, 2010, from Encyclopædia Britannica Online: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/187819/Church-of-England
Anglicanism. (2010). In Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved April 14, 2010, from Encyclopædia Britannica Online: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/24861/Anglicanism

Sunday, April 11, 2010

Western Europe, circa 1500


Stephen Castaneda
Essay 1 – Paradigm Shift Around 1500 C.E.
Word Count:1182

If the seed of modernity was sewn during the Italian Renaissance, then the changes in Western European civilization around the beginning of the 16th century C.E. arguably represent its flowering. Charlemagne's (742-814) Empire would crumble into feudalism. The predominant socioeconomic arrangement became centered around large landowners and was built on the manorialism economic model, wherein serfs were bound to work the land of the local lord who provided the serfs with physical security from land-grabbing neighboring lords, and, according to Perry, the “right to cultivate fields.” Naturally, manorialism tended to lead society's focus away from cities and toward rural manors, and resulted in an entrenched system wherein there existed, as Perry sums it up, three social classes: “clergy who prayed, lords who fought, and peasants who toiled.” One can't help but draw comparisons between the plight of a medieval serf and that of a slave on an early American plantation.
This was, more or less, the socioeconomic structure that faced the Italian Renaissance and against which its leaders rebelled to plant the modern nucleus. Perry points out that during the Renaissance, “many medieval ways and attitudes persisted.” In his classic A History of Western Philosophy, Bertrand Russell argues that the remarkable cultural achievements that we tend to assume when we think of the Renaissance actually boiled down to a relatively small handful of geniuses under the patronage of very rich, and shockingly pragmatic feudal lords, as well as clergy who were equally rich and morally oblivious.
As an example we'll discuss the political philosopher Niccolò Machiavelli (1649-1527), arguably the most famous pure thinker of the Italian Renaissance, his ideal “new prince” expediently consolidates feudal power by manipulation, deception, even violence – whatever is most expedient (source book). Machiavelli demonstrates his keen perception of humanity with a long list of character traits of varying degrees of desirability. Acknowledging that each individual ruler brings their own personality and vices to the table, he warns the Prince not to strive to give up all vices, but simply “to avoid the scandal of those vices which would lose him the state.” On the other hand, however, he advises the ruler to outright ignore scandal incurred as the result of action that was expedient for the maintenance of the state. Interestingly, he advises mercifulness, but stresses that one “must, however, take care not to misuse this mercifulness,” citing as an example the harsh rule of Cesare Borgia which united Romagna (temporarily). In my opinion, Machiavelli would most certainly have approved the two nuclear attacks against Japan in the Second World War. It was the expedient thing to do, since the attacks' collateral damage was judged to be much smaller than that which would be incurred by attempting to forcibly occupy the Japanese mainland. What is remarkable about Machiavelli in relation to his era is that he asserts that a ruler should put the logistical needs of the state above any other ethical code. The dominant medieval political paradigm was that the monarch ruled at the pleasure of God almighty, and that the ruler was obliged to the church for ethical cues. In this system, the church was closely involved with much of the inner workings of government.
In fact, the clergy's questionable involvement in public affairs, coupled with their unscrupulous ways – which in all fairness was somewhat necessary for medieval movers and shakers – led some to reassess the boundaries of the clergy's jurisdiction. Two main players would, for very different reasons, almost inadvertently bring about one of the largest societal paradigm shifts in western history. The two figures are Martin Luther (1483-1546) and Henry VIII of England (1491-1547) and the instrument of change was the Protestant Reformation. Machiavelli had turned away from medieval politics, Renaissance artists from medieval art (which Perry tells us was almost exclusively religious), so did the Reformation turn away from medieval religious attitudes. Without going too deeply into their individual histories, Luther was a German clergy member who rebelled against the church's waning greed and blatant immorality, while Henry VIII was a worldly monarch, probably more motivated by an opportunity to break with the ethical and economic authority of Rome, which must have,to him, seemed half a world away.
Whatever its motivations, the Protestant Reformation happened quickly – Perry tells us that in the 30 short years prior to the death of Henry VIII, nearly 25% of western Europeans had converted to some form of Protestantism. The significance cannot be overstated – this is a populace that only half a century earlier sincerely believed the fate of one's everlasting soul depended entirely on Vatican intervention. As for religious freedom, we know that Protestantism believed in a democratization of faith – the Protestant God was more available, more personal, and Bibles were translated into common languages – but persecution by Protestants was often just as harsh as Papal persecution. The real revolution, as we discussed in class, was that in Protestant lands, the government was finally free from religious oversight. Machiavelli's prince now had a land to govern – not based on divine right and for the glorification of God, but based on the idea that the ruler's main concern should be the successful management of the state.
So we have discussed the beginnings of major paradigm shifts in art, politics, and religion. To finish up, I'll briefly discuss a fourth area of enlightenment just beginning to blossom around 1500 – that of science; or to maintain the tone of this essay, a break from medieval reliance on an Aristotelian/Biblical view of the natural world to that of an empirical and mathematical scientist. The eminent thinker in this regard is probably Copernicus. The week 2 handout even labels the paradigm shift the Copernican Revolution. It outlines 4 compelling (to medieval minds) arguments that the Earth was stationary, from purely scriptural – Psalm 93; to wildly speculative – that it's impossible for a body as heavy as the Earth to move, especially as fast as suggested; to the amazingly empirical – that if the Earth were spinning, why does an object dropped from a height fall straight down, instead of away from the direction of rotation? (The modern answer is two-fold. First, inertia causes the dropped object to move toward the direction of rotation, and second the object actually does fall away a bit, but the distance is much too small to measure). In my opinion, the most significant contribution of the Copernican Revolution lies hidden in the famous epicycles. The word for planet comes from a word meaning “wanderer” because they were not stationary against the stars, and some inexplicably moved for a time in one direction, reversed direction for a brief time, only to loop back and maintain a single overall orbit – something not even the sun did. The medieval cosmological model required the planet's rotation (around the Earth) to contain many epicycles. The Copernican model nearly eliminated epicycles, thereby giving modern scientist's one of their most cherished ideals – that all things being equal, the simpler model is almost always more accurate.

History Questions 1


Stephen Castaneda
Week 3 Questions

  1. Why were the Tudors successful monarchs?

    1. Success in War of the Roses(1455-85)

    2. Henry's reign focused on consolidating and extending his power

    3. Break from Papacy.

    4. Defeat of Spanish Armada(Elizabeth, 1588)

    5. Strength & decisiveness of Elizabeth as a ruler

  2. Describe the problems of the Stuart Kings – English royal absolutists – crown & it's court as sole governing body by divine right. Lacked adequate social & institutional base for absolutism, including no standing army and no massive wealth with which to purchase them.

    1. James I (1603-1625)

      1. did not include Parliament in foreign policy decisions

      2. absolutist playbook:

        1. consolidated & centralized power

        2. win over aristocracy with titles and offices

        3. granted monopolies to certain merchants

    2. Charles I (1625-1649)

      1. ruled through advisors

      2. two goals

        1. rid country of Puritans

        2. rid country of remaining absolutist resistance

      3. First English revolution (1640-1660)

        1. Charles needs money to fight the Scots, but Parliament demands certain rights

          1. Consultation in matters of taxation

          2. trial by jury

          3. habeas corpus

          4. truly Protestant church of and for laity

        2. Charles refused, tried to arrest parliament civil war breaks out(1642) led by Oliver Cromwell

      4. Monarchy restored 1660, crisis flares up again, is resolved by Glorious Revolution (1688-89)

        1. Consolidated power over British Isles.

        2. Cromwell drives Irish to barren west side of island

      5. Cromwell's New Model Army financed by supporters of Parliament and led by gentlemen farmers defeats king, his aristocrats, and church

      6. Charles executed January, 1649

  3. Explain how the following weakened England's monarchs

    1. Oliver Cromwell & the Puritan Revolution

      1. Cromwell's New Model Army financed by supporters of Parliament and led by gentlemen farmers defeats king, his aristocrats, and church

      2. 2 years after Cromwell's death, country was adrift without leadership

    2. The glorious Revolution – See above – 2.4

    3. The English Declaration of Rights –

      1. in reaction to James II power grab Declaration for Liberty of Conscience(Apr. 4, 1687)

      2. King fathered Catholic heir, most all powerful factions joined to invite William & Mary (king's daughter & her Dutch Protestant husband). Their ascension was accompanied by the Bill of Rights (Jan 22, 1689)

      3. BOR's major points:

        1. “[guarantee] … that their religion, laws, and liberties may not again be in danger of being subverted.”

        2. Got back the many powers James II had usurped, namely the monarch may not arbitrarily dispense with laws, set up religious courts, spend money without Parliament's permission

        3. No standing army during peacetime

        4. free elections

        5. freedom of political speech

        6. no excessive bail or “cruel & unusual punishment”

        7. etc.

  4. Explain how:

    1. the policies of Cardinal Richelieu strengthened France

      1. Richelieu chief minister to Louis XIII (1624-42)

      2. “great architect of French absolutism”

        1. Ethics: raison d'état – ethical patriotism

        2. increased power of central bureaucracy

        3. attacked regional powers (usu. Protestant)

        4. limited the powers of aristocracy (i.e. no more duels, grievances must go through court system)

        5. Joined forces with anti-Spanish Protestants in the Thirty Years' War. The victory made France prominent continental power.

    2. the policies of Louis XIV weakened France

      1. Motivated by the Fronde uprising (against absolutism)

      2. Huge, powerful, centralized bureaucracy

      3. Extravagant spending on luxuries (Versailles)

      4. Large army that he turned on Protestants, the Holy Roman Empire, and Spain drained the French coffers.

      5. Taxes were exorbitant and levied disproportionately on the poor

Luke + Leia


http://www.discountpartysupplies.com/blog/2010/04/07/20-party-cakes-gone-horribly-wrong/


Thursday, April 8, 2010

Spent the last few days in the hospital because of stomach crap.

Monday, March 29, 2010

The Enlightenment


Stephen Castaneda
HS240H First night assignment

According to Perry, the philosophes were the “combative intellectuals and pundits” who were “the leaders of the enlightenment.” These individuals of diverse backgrounds, though not entirely of the same mind on all issues, shared a few general beliefs that were inspired by the new science. Among their most cherished ideals were carefully ordered freedom, tolerance, and, according to Encyclopedia Britannica, a “conviction of the supremacy and efficacy of human reason.” In my assessment, the 17th century belonged to a small handful of geniuses, including Copernicus, Galileo, Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz, and Newton, whereas the 18th century philosophes represented a great democratization of science and thought that caused massive historical changes including the American Revolution.
Before discussing some of these great enlightenment leaders, let's define the enlightenment properly. According to the chronology presented by Perry, the enlightenment began in 1685 with the revocation of the Edict of Nantes – which justified the persecution of Protestants in France and caused mass exodus of its intellectuals – and ended in 1789 with the beginning of the French Revolution. As late as 1784, in his essay, “What is Enlightenment?,” Kant denied that his was a fully enlightened age, but rather was still an “age of enlightenment,” and he expresses great optimism for the future. As was typical of enlightenment thought, Kant rejected the traditional view of humans as mostly detestable, and argued that intellectual “laziness and cowardice” were the major factors holding humankind back, not lack of intelligence. He even attacks those of means who would outsource the “tedious job” of thinking to others. Clearly, enlightenment thinkers hoped that all people would take it upon themselves to pursue education and to question previously unquestionable institutions, such as political tyranny and the domination of the church.
Voltaire (1694–1778) was a Parisian poet, who traveled to the Dutch Republic and then to London, where he enjoyed enormous freedom of thought and “witnessed social and religious tolerance.”(Perry) He came to identify with the anger of exiled French Protestants toward the French church. In his writings, Voltaire condemns superstition, specifically the sentencing to death of “over a hundred thousand accused witches,” including one in Würzburg as late as 1749. He calls for complete tolerance of ideas, arguing that each citizen “be permitted to believe and think that which his reason rightly or wrongly dictates,” so long as those beliefs did not “disturb the public order.” This was in stark contrast to the strictness of the church in his time, which excommunicated or killed those who did not subscribe to the church's dogmas, no matter how “inaccessible to human intellect” they might be.
In order to understand Rousseau, we must first understand Hobbes, from whom Rousseau borrowed the idea that the governors served according to a social contract with the governed. Where Hobbes believed this to be a one-time contract creating a hereditary monarchy, Rousseau called for the contract to be continually renewed. According to Perry, Rousseau's political ideal was the city-state of ancient Greece, where all citizens participated in important decisions, and could be trusted to make decisions that were in the best interests of the state. This was in opposition to what he saw in his time as a corrupt system where the rich and powerful misused their positions to fortify their status and wealth, while oppressing the less fortunate. Interestingly, Perry tells us that Rousseau did not identify with the philosophes, who he accused of being “corrupted by easy living” and salon culture.
John Locke was a seventeenth century English political philosopher to whom we owe much of our modern ideas about the roles and responsibilities of government. According to Perry, he believed the right to govern was “derived from the consent of the governed and was a form of contract.” He believed in certain natural rights, such as life, liberty, and property and that if a government ruled arbitrarily and denied any of these rights, the people had the right to overthrow that government. From Locke's Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690), we see one of the great leaps forward in the history of epistemology in the concept of the tabula rasa, or blank slate, that represented each individual's mind at birth. He argues against religious revelation, asserting that all ideas must come from either “sensible qualities” such as things we taste, smell, see, or otherwise experience through our senses, or else from the “internal operations of our minds” – that which we are able to deduce logically from what we have observed.
To historians, enlightened despotism refers specifically to the High Enlightenment (second half of the eighteenth century) rulers “Frederick the Great in Prussia; Catherine the Great in Russia; Charles III in Spain; Maria Theresa and ...her son Joseph II in Austria; and Louis XV in France.” (Perry) To the philosophes, the phrase, probably coined by Diderot, referred to an ideal ruler who was strong and authoritative, but who allowed for freedom of exchange, both commercial and intellectual. In reality, Perry paints a less favorable picture of the enlightened despots, for whom enlightenment ideals were to be exploited for political expediency. For instance, Joseph II quickly reimposed censorship after French Revolution pamphlets began circulating under the liberalized publishing laws he enacted in the 1780's.
Finally we come to Adam Smith, who many have called the father of modern economics. Locke had already argued that the role of government was to promote the best interests of its citizens, and the new economic theory, personified in Adam Smith, asserted that the best economic interest was to allow business and trade to its own best interests. Smith saw the value of a good or service as the sum of the labor costs associated with its production. Labor was a commodity like any other, whose value is determined by the laws of supply and demand. In modern times, Smith and his laissez faire free-market ideas have been criticized for selling the public interest to the highest bidder. Another weakness in his theories lies in its reliance on self-interest governing the market, while it has been observed time and again that people and organizations often make erroneous decisions that are not in their own best interests, let alone in the interests of society.

References
Perry, Marvin. (2009). Western civilization. Boston, MA: 2009.
Perry, Marvin, Joseph Peden, and Theodore Laue. Sources of the Western Tradition Volume II. 7th ed. II. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin College Div, 2007.
philosophe. (2010). In Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved March 29, 2010, from Encyclopædia Britannica Online: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/456709/philosophe



The more the Christian religion is divine, the less it pertains to man to require it; if God made it, God will sustain it without you.
--Voltaire

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Another first night assignment I never turned in.


As a computer scientist who is relatively well versed in the physical sciences, I like precise definitions. If the goal is to calculate the ratio π to n decimal places, one must first explain to the machine, in no uncertain terms, one or several of the handful of ways that mathematicians have worked out for calculating π. Religion is somewhat different, in that where its definition may once have been extremely limited, in the modern era, one may define religion in nearly any terms. Furthermore, as long as one's belief system is sincere, it is usually shown nothing but respect in most modern cultural settings. In that spirit, I intend to begin this paper with my my own, fairly unique, take on religion – the sort of definition in which I would not be able to indulge myself in most of my other classes. Then, time and space permitting, I'll discuss how much my definition of religion was changed by taking the sister course to this one, which is to say, not much.
I was raised in a hallelujah church. Among the many precepts a young person growing up in one of these churches must accept without question, is that of monotheism. Err, wait. There's that whole thing about the three parts of God, which are all quite distinct and unified at the same time. But still, they were all the same God, which is the only real God, and whose name is called Yahweh. Err, wait. Yahweh is His Hebrew name, and there's that little issue where most people who could recognize Hebrew if they heard it definitely don't believe in all three of the gods that make up the one. So how could there be just one?
Such was the confusion in which a reflective, well read, young man found himself while discovering pot in high school and just after. During this highly inquisitive time in my life, I explored many ideas, perhaps the most important of which was Hinduism. I have the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) to thank for this.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Modern meaning of mythology


Stephen Castaneda
First night assignment: The modern meaning of mythology

Mythology is a nearly mystical word almost begging not to have a definition pinned upon it. Of course we, as scholars, are somewhat loathe to discuss a topic without first putting forth our best effort to agree on a definition of all the terms we use. According to The New Student's Reference Work, the word mythology has two meanings. The more academic and etymologically correct definition is simply the study of various myths, in the same way that biology is the study of biological systems. This definition, like most self-referential definitions, is not very satisfying. The second definition, the one the authors claim is more common, is “a collection or system of myths held by a certain people.” They go on to define myth as a “sham history,” which, while patently false, is held by a certain people to be both true and extremely important. This definition was written nearly a century ago, and I would argue that it shows its age somewhat.
In his introduction to The Power of Myth, Bill Moyers discusses the relationship Joseph Campbell developed with the filmmaker, George Lucas. Clearly, Lucas and his colleague, Stephen Spielberg, are two of the great myth makers of my time. Moyers discusses Lucas's nod to Campbell in Star Wars, and there has been scholarly work on Spielberg's E.T. The Extraterrestrial as a Jesus myth (Tomasulo, 2001). I recall my father taking me to see Star Wars when I was just five, and can personally attest to the power the myth had over me. It had everything – a reluctant young hero, mystical powers some chose to use for good, others for evil, Ultimate triumph of the spirited guerrilla over an imposing and impersonal domineering power. All these things I experienced without either the benefits or biases that an older, more educated person would have brought to the theater, and I certainly was too young to catch the triumph of human over technology theme alluded to by Moyers. But I felt the “power of myth” rooting for Skywalker and friends. Thus, I think a more modern definition of mythology would not include the bit about it being held by some to be true. Certainly not even the most gullible and still-believing-in-Santa of my young friends ever believed Luke and Darth Vader really went head to head, not even a long time ago or far, far away. But the myth had much more power over my young mind than did, for instance, the myth of Robin Hood, which actually had some possible basis in history.
Which brings us to another flaw in the New Student's Reference's definition. Mythology need not necessarily be false. Moyers alludes to the myth of John F. Kennedy, and indeed, there exists a cultural mythology associated with the entire Kennedy family. An even more modern example is the myth of Barack Obama, whose rise to the most important office in the U.S. has great meaning for a great many peoples. For instance, to African Americans, he represents progress on the equality front. This feeling also extends to many other minority groups for whom the possibility of their sons or daughters someday rising to that kind of position is now a distinct reality. It even extends to many non-ethnic minorities. And then there is the manufactured, though no less real, myth of hope and change. I think it's safe to say that a large majority of those approximately 53% who voted for Obama believe (or at least believed) in the hope and change message. The point is that even though it can be argued that the hope & change mythology was entirely manufactured by political spin doctors, it is no less real to those who believe it, and to some extent, I think the entire nation uses it as the basis of the expectations we have of this president and his administration.
So clearly, our definition of the word mythology has changed somewhat in the last century, though we still share some rather powerful myths. When I took “mythology” in high school as recently as the late 1980's, the course definitely should have been named “Greek mythology,” as the rich diversity of world mythology was not to be found. Soon after high school, I forced my way through a second-hand copy of Campbell's The masks of God: creative mythology, though now I barely remember it beyond the vague recollection at being amazed by the parallels found in myths from peoples who geographically could not possibly share a cultural heritage. Looking at some of the reading assignments for this course, I look forward to experiencing that amazement again, this time through adult eyes.
References

Bierlein, J. F. (1994). Parallel myths. New York, NY: Random House, Inc..
Campbell, Joseph, Moyers, Bill, & Flowers, Betty. (1991). The Power of myth. New York, NY: Anchor.
The New Student's Reference Work/Mythology. (2007, November 29). In Wikisource, The Free Library. Retrieved 18:29, March 22, 2010, from http://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=The_New_Student%27s_Reference_Work/Mythology&oldid=510619
Tomasulo, F. P. (2001). The gospel according to Spielberg in E.T.: The extra-terrestrial. Quarterly Review of Film and Video, 18(3), 273-282. doi:10.1080/10509200109361529